The underlying idea
A geographical indication takes a name that has come to mean a particular food from a particular place, and turns it into a registered legal category. The mechanism is a written specification, lodged and published, setting out what the product is, where it must be made, from what, and how.
Once registered, the name is protected. Producers who meet the specification may use it. Producers who do not, may not, and imitation, evocation and misuse of the name are addressed by the scheme rules.
In the UK, these schemes are administered by Defra, which maintains public registers of protected names. Applications go through a defined process including scrutiny and an opportunity for objection.
Three designations, three different promises
Protected designation of origin. The strongest geographical link. Every part of the production, processing and preparation must take place in the defined geographical area, and the qualities or characteristics of the product must be essentially or exclusively due to that area.
Protected geographical indication. A weaker but still real link. At least one of the stages of production, processing or preparation must take place in the area, and the product must have a quality, reputation or other characteristic attributable to that geographical origin.
Traditional speciality guaranteed. Not a geographical claim at all. It protects a traditional composition or production method for a named product, without restricting where it may be made.
The difference between the first two is the one most often missed. Both use a place name. Only one requires the whole product to have been made there.
| Designation | Geographical requirement | What it protects |
|---|---|---|
| Protected designation of origin | All production stages in the defined area | A name tied to a place and its characteristics |
| Protected geographical indication | At least one stage in the defined area | A name with a quality or reputation linked to a place |
| Traditional speciality guaranteed | None | A traditional composition or production method |
Structure set out by this newsroom from the published rules named in the sources below. It is not a survey, a measurement or a market study.
What is in a specification
The specification is the substance of the protection, and it is public. It typically covers the name being protected, a description of the product including its physical, chemical, microbiological or organoleptic characteristics, a definition of the geographical area, evidence that the product originates from that area, a description of the production method, and the link between the product and the area.
Because it is public and detailed, a protected name is one of the very few pack claims a shopper can look up in full. The register entry states exactly what the product has to be.
Verification is carried out by control authorities or approved bodies, and producers using a protected name are subject to checks that the specification has been followed.
What protection does not do
A protected name is not a quality mark in the sense of a rating. It certifies conformity with a specification, not superiority over anything else. Two products, one with a protected name and one without, may differ in nothing that matters to a given shopper.
It is not a claim about scale, about craft or about a small producer. Registrations cover products made at every scale, and the specification says nothing about the size of the business.
It is not a nutritional or health claim of any kind, and it makes no statement about the merits of eating the product.
And it is not a guarantee that every ingredient originated in the area, unless the specification says so. The rules on what has to originate locally vary between designations and between specifications.
Generic names and the boundary of protection
Not every food name that sounds geographical is protected. Some names have become generic, meaning they have come to denote a type of product rather than a product from a place, and generic names cannot be registered.
This is one of the more contested areas of the whole system, because the line between a name that still denotes origin and one that has become the name of a category is a matter of evidence and argument. Objection procedures exist precisely because these questions are not obvious.
For a shopper, the practical consequence is that a place name on a pack may be a protected designation, a generic product name, or a marketing reference to a style. The symbol and the register are what distinguish them.
Reading a protected name properly
Look for the designation symbol, which indicates that the name is registered and which of the three schemes applies. Then, if it matters, look the name up on the register, where the specification will tell you what the producer had to do.
Where a pack uses a place name without a symbol, the questions become different. Is the place name part of the legal name of the food, a description of style, or an origin statement? Origin statements are separately regulated, and where the origin of the food is given, additional rules can apply to the origin of the primary ingredient.
Where this stops
This article explains a registration system. It does not recommend any product, does not compare protected products with unprotected ones, and offers no view on taste, quality or value. It makes no nutritional claim, and dietary questions belong with the NHS or a registered dietitian.
Elsewhere on Feedworthy. Artisan, farmhouse, handmade: the words with nothing behind them. What a promotion actually costs a supplier.